Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is no reason to assume that the correct length parameters would be passed to safercopy. Indeed, there are many buffer overflows and off-by-one errors in C programs which involve buffers with explicit size values instead of null-terminated C strings.

The real problem with C is that it relies on bare pointers, where it would have been better to use slice-type structures that describe a buffer by pairing the base pointer and size, so that they are naturally kept in sync. This article takes a lot of time to "deconstruct" C strings, but never gets to the real issue.

The "stylistic issue" is also debatable. With the indentation given in the example, nobody would think that the "while-loop will loop both if-statements", as the author claims.



In short, Zed had all of Rob Pike's sneering anger and none of his technical mettle.

What has Zed said about C that wasn't already answered more thoroughly by Go?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: