Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Calling search unusable is hyperbole. I've used search on discord many times to find a discussion from the past.


In the past month I've had to use Discord search to find something important twice. Both times it took 20+ minutes and when I actually found the results I noticed that I typed things that ought to have given me the results but just didn't. In one other case I never actually found the correct message but found the URL I was looking for elsewhere and decided to try it out to see if it'd find the correct message. Pasting literally the exact URL did point to the correct message but no other combination of host, part of URL, etc. would.

While that's not technically unusable it's far beyond the level where I'll even try to find something in Discord unless it's very important.


Some people have higher expectations and needs than single word matching.


Discord does support other search features. It would be nice to have a wildcard search, for sure--but, in my experience, even on busy and large servers I very rarely can't narrow something down to what I was looking for with `from` and `in` along with not-just-single-keyword matching.

But also, it's chat, so I don't really care if on the once-per-month I use the search I have to think about it for a second, because all the other stuff is there and it's good.


It’s amazing someone just doesn’t connect an existing open source search to it

Oh wait they’re probably using nosql


They're using ScyllaDB, which is indeed a NoSQL database. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2xmFOAUhsk

Their main consideration is latency, not search.


At least they're large enough that that makes somewhat sense.


Discord is pretty disjointed though as a first time experience




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: