Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Downloading is legal in Switzerland. For a nice authoritative source, here's the Swiss Federal Institute for Intellectual Property (part of the Department of Justice and Police)[0]: "Downloading copyright-protected works for private use is permitted in Switzerland (Art. 19 CopA)."

The mentioned legal basis is [1].

Note that this applies strictly to downloading though. Participating in a torrent swarm (where uploading is also happening) is not permitted. That's where the technicality you mention comes in: until recently, it was illegal to monitor internet users for copyright enforcement purposes, which meant it was illegal to monitor a torrent swarm, which meant you could somewhat safely seed torrents, despite it being illegal.

That loophole was recently removed however.

[0]: https://www.ige.ch/en/intellectual-property/counterfeiting-a...

[1]: https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/1993/1798_1798_1798/en#ar...



downloading anything since 1997 in Switzerland: BBS, FXP, IRC/XDCC then later on gnutella, DC++, torrents and one click hosters.

De jure it's not really legal anymore since they updated the law... De facto nobody cares as long as you're not making a business out of it.

Same goes for the place I live since 2016: Thailand.

Though: Not pirating for professional stuff, only for private stuff. I still support software/media by buying the things I want to support.


> De jure it's not really legal anymore since they updated the law... De facto nobody cares as long as you're not making a business out of it.

My claim was founded on authoritative sources, including the law itself. If you want to contradict that claim, you'll need to back it up.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: