Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When I first moved to New York, I spent weeks living in an AirBnB place before finding a real apartment. Same thing when I moved to London. I could have found a place via other means (Craigslist, or pay tons of money to some real estate agent) but this was much better.

This will inhibit mobility and hurt newcomers to the city, especially in the young technology/creative classes. But what sort of politician would actually care, as long as they're not politically active in our jurisdiction yet, am I right?



As someone who happened to be a young adult before the advent of iPhones and AirBnB I can promise you that it was indeed possible for people to do things without technologies available since 2010.

I successfully moved to a number of different cities with neither money nor job prospects. It involved using the ancient human rituals of "using a telephone", "riding the bus", "speaking with other persons" and "walking around".

In the process I had to deal with some minor inconveniences and sometimes things didn't go exactly the way I wanted. The horror!


Yes, but these days, that kind of stuff is only something old or even the poor people might do. You're clearly old, QED! I, however, am a liberty loving rugged individual, so treating me that way is unacceptable.

Can't you just understand: what you're advocating is pretty much legal torture of high-income Americans on a site about Web 2.0 startups?!?!? /s


What folksinger is snarkily and rudely trying to say is that there are other short-term alternatives, such as motels. Also, any listings made by people physically present would have been legal.

I agree that it limits mobility but the law also protects residents from constant, disruptive behavior from serial short-term renters.

I have never lived near a serial short-term rental, but I imagine I would dislike it if I lived next door to one.


Anybody who claims that there is no possible benefit, or increased efficiency of housing stock usage, as a result of services like AirBnB is a fool.

But that doesn't mean that an unrestricted free-for-all is the only possible alternative.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: